Go to Table of Contents
Table of Contents
Diana, Goddess of the Hunt for Ancestors!
Go to Every-Name Index
Every-Name Index
HARRINGTON Early Immigrants to New England
American and other "transplanted" genealogists typically seek, first, to identify their immigrant ancestor and, second, to identify their immigrant's origin (i.e., to "cross the pond").  There are two early HARRINGTON immigrants to New England, namely, Robert HARRINGTON of Watertown, MA, and Benjamin HARRINGTON of Providence, RI, with a great many descendants who have been searching for their origins, for decades.

There is a line of HARINGTONs in England with some spectacular ancestry, which has created a great incentive among living HARRINGTONs to connect to them.  Especially desirable is a descent from John HARINGTON & Mary ROGERS, of Somerset, mainly because Mary has royalty in her pedigree.  Most try to connect through their son, James, but other connections are alleged, as well.

Despite all the various connections for them seen in secondary sources, the parents of Robert and Benjamin remain unindentified (see Source 1, below).  There is, however, one thing we do know for certain: Y-DNA testing has proven, beyond any doubt, that Robert and Benjamin are not only not brothers, they are not related in genealogical time.  Robert and Benjamin represent two different origins of surname HARRINGTON.  At best, only one of them, and probably neither, descends from the illustrious HARINGTONs because, and if for no other reason, if they had they would have been well known for that connection in their own time, and they weren't (see Source 2).

And the bottom line is, and as of this writing (30 Dec 2011):  Unless and until we have a proven patrilineal descendant of the Somerset HARINGTONs Y-DNA tested, it is premature for any HARRINGTON of unproven ancestry to be claiming descent from them.  If you are such a HARINGTON, please join the HARRINGTON Y-DNA Surname Project and put this issue to rest.

As it stands, the two major New England progenitors of HARRINGTON are:

Robert HARRINGTON, b. 1615/6, England to Watertown, MA
Patrilineal descendants of Robert have a Y-DNA match with a patrilineal descendant of William HARRINGTON of Essex. 

Benjamin HARRINGTON, b. 1618, England to Providence, RI
So far, the descendants of Benjamin have no match "across the pond." 

The following two are not of concern to us because they left no descendants surnamed HARRINGTON:

Abraham ERRINGTON, bap. 19 Jun 1622, England to Cambridge, MA
Abraham is an ERRINGTON, not a HARRINGTON or HERRINGTON, and he is descended from Edward ERRINGTON of Denton, Northumberland.  Abraham's line daughtered out in the second generation.

Rebecca HARRINGTON, b. ca. 1625; d. 4 Dec 1713; m. John WATSON
I have not worked on Rebecca's genealogy.


1.  Patricia Ann Scherzinger.  1996. Colonial Americans of Royal and Noble Descent:  Alleged, Proven, and Disproven.  Heritage Books, Bowie, MD.
  Benjamin (Harrington or Hearnden) - b abt 1624, m Elizabeth White - the immigrant LDS18,71; sufficient proof of alleged royal ancestry is lacking
  Daniel - b abt 1748, m Sarah Carpenter - desc/o Benjamin Harrington LDS18
  Elizabeth - b abt 1650, m Stephen Northrop - desc/o Benjamin Harrington LDS71
  John - b 1651, m Hannah Winter - desc/o Robert Harrington LDS82
  John - b 1662, m Lydia Cranston - desc/o Benjamin Harrington LDS18
  Jonathan - b 1704, m Sarah Foster - desc/o Benjamin Harrington LDS18
p. 249 HARRINGTON (cont.)
  Patience - chr 1697, m David Stowell - desc/o Robert Harrington LDS82
  Robert - b 1616, m Susannah George - the immigrant LDS17; royalty not proven
  Sarah - b 1671, m Joseph Winship - desc/o Robert Harrington LDS17
  Susanna - b 1688, m Joshua Kendall - desc/o Robert Harrington LDS85
  Thomas - b. 1665, m Rebecca Bemis - desc/o Robert Harrington LDS85
p. 562 LDS = Michel L. Call, Royal Ancestors of Some LDS Families, 1972

2.  Fredrick Lewis Weis.  1958.  Early Generations of the Family of Robert Harrington of Watertown, Massachusetts, 1634, and Some of His Descendants.  Self-published, Worcester, MA (online at HeritageQuest at Genealogy.com):
p. 9

One of the difficulties in dealing with the New England Harrington families is to keep them separate.  There were at least three early Harrington families.

I.  Robert Harrington of Watertown, born in England in 1616, who settled in New England in 1634.

II.  Abraham Harrington (sic) of Cambridge, whose male descent died out in a generation or two.

III.  Benjamin Harrington of Providence, Rhode Island, an entirely different family, possibly though not necessarily, related to the other two...

p. 10 ...Genealogists have frequently grouped Robert, Benjamin, and Abraham together as three brothers.  However, there is no least scrap of evidence that such was the case.  It has frequently been said they they were the children of John and Elizabeth (Clinton) Harington, for which there is even less foundation.

There were, to be sure, a number of John Haringtons (note the single "r") in England at this period, who were descendants of the ancient Haryngton family.  But had one of these come to New England in the early days, he would at once have been as well known as Dudley, Saltonstall, Winthrop, or Vane, and the other distinguished founders of New England.  No such person appears...

(DGM as of 5 Sep 2015)
Keywords for search engines:  genetic genealogy; USA, US, United States, Massachusetts, Rhode Island

Contact Home
Table of
Everything I have is online at this web site.  I have no further information, so please don't write asking me if I do.
On the other hand, if you feel I've made an error, please don't hesitate to notify me, but in which case,

please include a link to the page you are referencing.
There are over 18,000 pages on this web site, and I simply don't remember every page, much less every person on every page.

"The Cloud" is double-speak for "dumb terminal on a main frame." Been there; done that. Never again.
You are giving away not only your privacy, but control of your data, your apps, and your computer to a corporation. Is that really where you want to go?
The IT guys on the big iron hated the Personal Computer because it gave users freedom and power; now they've conned you into being back under their control.
Table of Contents
Go to Table of Contents
Privacy Policy ______
Every-Name Index
Go to Every-Name Index