MacAULAY Y-DNA Comparison

Table of Contents

Diana, Goddess of the Hunt — for Ancestors!

Every-Name Index

Comparison of Groups from the MacAULAY Y-DNA Surname Project

Below is a comparison of two groups from the MacAULAY Y-DNA Surname Project at FTDNA to aid in a discussion at the R1b-YDNA Yahoo Group (12/13 March 2015; update 21 Jun 2015; update 10 Feb 2016). To understand how I use color in this table, please see my web page on "Signature Markers."

The two groups from the MacAULAY project are closely related enough to be considered the same family in genealogical time, with the possible exception of #327031, who needs to upgrade to 111 markers. The "family" modal values used below are based on the combined two groups. The sample size here is small enough that the modal values are easily swayed by the simple happenstance of who's been tested. In particular, we have only nine individuals tested to 111 markers, so we don't have a very strong modal. Needless to say, it would make analysis of these results much easier if everyone would upgrade to 111 markers and more people were tested.

Legend
Cyan	Haplogroup R1b-P312 modal values
Orange	"Hgp R1b - Scots Modal to Antrim Group 1"
Yellow	"Hgp R1b - Scots Modal to Antrim Group 2"
Deep Cyan	a possible branching marker within Group 2
Magenta	a signature marker for Family I (Groups 1 + 2)
Purple	an individual from Group 2 who needs 111 markers
Electric Green	the GRANTHAM individual from Group 2
Red	a private — and, thus, presumably recent — mutation

You never know where (in which Panel) a family's signature markers will appear. In this case, half of them are in Panels 1 thru 4, while the other half are in Panel 5, which demonstrates just one reason to test Panel 5. The GRANTHAM individual likely has an NPE, but it could be the biological connection with the others may be just prior to surname adoption.

To see more of the table without scrolling, temporarily reduce the text size in your browser.
Genetic Distances are from the Family I modal values, not the R1b-P312 modal values.
FTDNA SNP Path: R1b-P25/M343 > L389 > P297 > M269 > L150 > L23 > L51 > L151 > P311 > P312 > DF27 > ZZ12_1 > ZZ19_1 > FGC11369 > FGC11397 > Y17787

F A M I L Y	G R O U P	Kit#	Surname	Most Downstream Positive SNP Actually Tested	Genetic Distance (per panel)					Panel 1 — Standard Markers 1-12												Panel 2 — Standard Markers 13-25													Panel 3 — Standard Markers 26-37												Panel 4 — Standard Markers 38-67																														Panel 5 — Standard Markers 68-111																																												Modals Known Patrilineal Line Ancestry
					Genetic Distance (per panel)					STR												PP3													PP5												MP6										MP7													MP8							MP9 [mixed]								MP10 [EA]										MP11 [SMGF]								MP12 [all new]									MP13 [mixed]
					12	25	37	67	111	3 9 3	3 9 0	19 / 3 9 4	3 9 1	a \| 3 8 5	b \| 3 8 5	4 2 6	3 8 8	4 3 9	i \| 3 8 9	3 9 2	ii \| 3 8 9	4 5 8	a \| 4 5 9	b \| 4 5 9	4 5 5	4 5 4	4 4 7	4 3 7	4 4 8	4 4 9	a \| 4 6 4	b \| 4 6 4	c \| 4 6 4	d \| 4 6 4	4 6 0	H4 \| G A T A	IIa \| Y C A	IIb \| Y C A	4 5 6	6 0 7	5 7 6	5 7 0	a \| C D Y	b \| C D Y	4 4 2	4 3 8	5 3 1	5 7 8	a \| S1 3 9 5	b \| S1 3 9 5	5 9 0	5 3 7	6 4 1	4 7 2	S1 4 0 6	5 1 1	4 2 5	a \| 4 1 3	b \| 4 1 3	5 5 7	5 9 4	4 3 6	4 9 0	5 3 4	4 5 0	4 4 4	4 8 1	5 2 0	4 4 6	6 1 7	5 6 8	4 8 7	5 7 2	6 4 0	4 9 2	5 6 5	7 1 0	4 8 5	6 3 2	4 9 5	5 4 0	7 1 4	7 1 6	7 1 7	5 0 5	5 5 6	5 4 9	5 8 9	5 2 2	4 9 4	5 3 3	6 3 6	5 7 5	6 3 8	4 6 2	4 5 2	4 4 5	A10 \| G A T A	4 6 3	4 4 1	1B 07 \| GG AA T	5 2 5	7 1 2	5 9 3	6 5 0	5 3 2	7 1 5	5 0 4	5 1 3	5 6 1	5 5 2	7 2 6	6 3 5	5 8 7	6 4 3	4 9 7	5 1 0	4 3 4	4 6 1	4 3 5
Hg R1b-P312 Modal Values										13	24	14	11	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	29	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	29	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	16	15	18	17	36	38	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	15	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12	35	15	9	16	12	26	26	19	12	11	13	12	10	9	12	12	10	11	11	30	12	13	24	13	10	10	21	15	19	13	24	17	12	15	24	12	23	18	10	14	17	9	12	11	R1b-P312 Modals
Family I Modal Values										13	24	14	10	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	19	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12	35	15	9	16	12	26	26	20	12	11	13	11	10	9	12	11	10	11	11	30	12	13	24	13	10	10	20	15	17	14	24	16	12	15	24	12	23	18	10	14	17	9	12	11	Family Modals

I	1	342681	McCauley	Y17787	2	0	1	0	3	13	24	14	9	11	14	12	12	13	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	20	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12	35	15	9	16	12	26	26	20	12	11	13	11	10	9	12	11	10	11	11	30	12	13	24	13	10	10	20	15	17	14	23	17	12	15	24	12	23	18	10	14	17	9	12	11	Samuel Wade² McCAULEY (1786-1849)	John¹ McCAULEY, Sr. (c1766-c1828) IRL > MS
		382774	McCauley		1	0	1	0	2	13	24	14	9	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	20	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12	36	15	9	16	12	26	26	20	12	11	14	11	10	9	12	11	10	11	11	30	12	13	24	13	10	10	20	15	17	14	23	16	12	15	24	12	23	18	10	14	17	9	12	11
		189006	McCauley		1	0	1	0		13	24	14	9	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	20	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12
		242251	McCauley	FGC11397	1	0	1			13	24	14	9	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	20	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12
		183723	McCauley		1	0	1			13	24	14	9	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	20	17	36	37	12	12																																																																											John² McCAULEY, Jr. (1796-1855)
		421619	McCauley		1	0	1	0		13	24	14	9	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	20	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12																																													John² McCAULEY, Jr. (1796-1855)
		266625	McCauley		1	0	1			13	24	14	9	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	20	17	36	37	12	12																																																																											McCAULEY
		250758	Mize		1	0	1			13	24	14	9	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	20	17	36	37	12	12																																																																											McCAULEY > MIZE NPE

	2	122148	McCaulley		1	0	1	0	1	13	24	14	10	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	31	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	18	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12	35	14	9	16	12	26	26	20	12	11	13	11	10	9	12	11	10	11	11	30	12	13	24	13	10	10	19	15	17	14	24	16	12	15	24	12	23	18	10	14	17	9	12	11	George McCAULLEY (1784-1827)
		309289	McCauley		1	1	0			13	24	14	10	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	31	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	16	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	19	17	36	37	12	12																																																																											McCAULEY
		115452	McCauley		0	2	0	0	2	13	24	14	10	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	29	15	15	16	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	19	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12	36	15	9	16	12	26	26	20	12	11	13	11	10	9	12	11	10	11	11	30	12	13	24	13	10	10	20	15	17	14	24	16	12	15	24	12	23	18	10	14	17	9	12	11	McCAULEY
		N18197	McAuley	Y17787	0	2	0	0	1	13	24	14	10	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	29	15	15	16	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	19	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12	35	15	9	16	12	26	26	20	12	11	13	11	10	9	12	11	10	11	11	30	13	13	24	13	10	10	20	15	17	14	24	16	12	15	24	12	23	18	10	14	17	9	12	11	McAULEY
		B47510	McCawley		0	1	0	0	0	13	24	14	10	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	29	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	19	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12	35	15	9	16	12	26	26	20	12	11	13	11	10	9	12	11	10	11	11	30	12	13	24	13	10	10	19	15	17	14	24	16	12	15	24	12	23	18	10	14	17	9	12	11	MacCAWLEY
		438499	Sadler		0	1	1	2	1	13	24	14	10	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	29	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	18	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	12	12	11	13	11	11	12	11	34	15	9	16	12	26	26	20	12	11	13	11	10	9	12	11	10	11	11	30	12	13	24	13	10	10	20	15	17	14	24	16	12	15	24	12	23	18	10	14	17	9	12	11	McCAULEY > SADLER NPE
		220228	Good		0	0	0	0		13	24	14	10	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	19	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12																																													McCAULEY > GOOD NPE
		193260	Macaulay		0	0				13	24	14	10	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17																																																																																							MACAULEY
		86047	McAuley	FGC11397	0	0	1	0	2	13	24	14	10	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	14	19	17	36	38	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12	35	15	9	16	12	26	26	20	12	11	13	11	10	9	12	11	10	11	11	30	12	12	24	13	10	10	21	15	17	14	24	16	12	15	24	12	23	18	10	14	17	9	12	11	John "Jack" McAULEY (c1782) co Antrim IRL
		41432	McAuley		0	0	2			13	24	14	10	11	14	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	16	13	19	17	36	37	12	12																																																																											McAULEY

I?	2?	327031	Macauley		2	1	3	1		13	23	14	10	11	15	12	12	12	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	29	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	15	13	18	17	35	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	14	12	11	13	11	11	12	12																																													John MACAULEY (1809-1889)

I?	2?	131897	Grantham		2	0	1	0	5	14	24	14	10	11	14	12	12	13	13	13	30	17	9	10	11	11	25	15	19	30	15	15	17	17	11	11	19	23	16	14	19	17	36	37	12	12	11	9	15	16	8	10	10	8	10	10	12	23	23	16	10	12	12	14	8	12	22	20	13	12	11	13	11	11	12	12	35	15	9	16	13	26	26	20	12	11	11	11	10	9	12	11	10	11	11	30	12	13	24	13	10	10	20	15	17	14	23	16	12	15	25	12	23	18	10	14	17	9	12	11	McCAULEY > GRANTHAM NPE

Discussion (21 Jun 2015):

With a GD of 7 at 67 markers, it's highly questionable whether #327031 (purple) actually belongs with Group 2 (yellow).

I'm always reluctant to declare the existence on an NPE, so I believe in having solid proof there is one. It may be that if everyone, or at least everyone in Group 2, upgrades to 111 markers, it will be confirmed that the GRANTHAM (#131897) belongs here.

To firmly establish whether the MIZE (#250758) has an NPE, I'd recommend upgrading to 111 markers.

Discussion (10 Feb 2016):

#342681 and #N18197 have tested positive for both FGC11397 and Y17787.

#242251 and #86047 have tested only FGC11397. Ideally, they will test Y17787 to confirm they are positive.

Two new individuals have been added to Group 2 (yellow), a SADLER and a GOOD, both of whom appear to have an NPE in their patrilineal line. I would recommend both test SNP Y17787 to be certain. Likewise our two previous NPEs, the GRANTHAM and the MIZE.

Contact

Home
Page

Table of
Contents

DNA
Hub