— born in Caldwell Co., KY:
4.  Henry S. SMITH, b. 1844/5
5.  Charles SMITH, b. 1848/9

1.  Family Group Sheet compiled by Georgie Tolleson and Betty Ann (Matthiesen) Cogliati.

2.  Anon.  1983/96.  Kentucky Marriage Records: from the Register of the Kentucky Historical Society.  Genealogical Publ. Co., Baltimore, MD (Broderbund CD-519):

p. 143

Smith, Strother Clark, Susannah....May 16, 1823    Beverly Stubblefield

Beverly STUBBLEFIELD married Susannah's sister, Nancy, two months later. 

3.  Census Index:  U.S. Selected Counties, 1830 (Broderbund CD-315):

1830	Smith, Strother	TN	Montgomery Co.	p. 48
1832	Smith, Strother	TN	Montgomery Co.

Based on the birthplaces of the children, this may not be our subject.  Then again, Montgomery Co., TN, is adjacent to Christian Co., KY, and Susannah's parents were married in Montgomery Co., TN.  Other SMITHs in Montgomery County were:  Aaron, Andrew, David L., Mrs. Dorcas, George, Mrs. Hannah, Henry H., Isaac, James, James Jr., James Sr., James M., Jesse, Joel, John, John Sr., John A., Joseph H., Josiah, Mark, Richard, Riley B., Robert W., Samuel, Sidney, Thomas A., Thomas N., William, William, Williamson.

4.  Census Index:  U.S. Selected Counties, 1840 (Broderbund CD-316):

1840

Smith, Strother

KY

Caldwell Co.

p. 4

Other SMITHs in Caldwell County were:  Abner W., Andrew, Edward J., Elias, Franklin, Garlin, George F., Hardy W., Jackson P., James W., James W., Leonard, Orsey, Peggy, Peter, Phoebe, Ransford, Rebecca, Robert, Solomon, Spence, Thomas, Thompson.

5.  1850 Census Index/Microfilm (online at GenealogyLibrary.com):  District No. 1, Caldwell Co., KY, p. 338B, 861/861, enumerated 28 Sep 1850 (extracted by Diana Gale Matthiesen):

Strother Smith	47	M	Farmer	4000	Virginia
Susan       "	42	F			Christian Cty Ky
Strother J. "	15	M			"
Ann E.      "	13	F			"
Asbury      "	9	M			"
Henry S.    "	5	M			Caldwell Cty Ky
Charles     "	1	M			"
George Dulin	30	M	Labourer		Tennessee

6.  Sam E. Hill.  1891.  Report of the Adjutant General of the State of Kentucky.  Frankfort, KY (repub. 1969 as Kentucky Soldiers of the War of 1812 by Genealogical Publ. Co., Baltimore, MD; Broderbund CD-519).

p. 313	Roll of Field and Staff, Porter's Regiment, Kentucky Militia, War of 1812-- Commanded by Lieutenant-Colonel Andrew Porter...
p. 323	Roll of Captain Samuel Gooden's Company... Names Rank Date of Appointment or Enlistment To what time Engaged or Enlisted Remarks Smith, Strother Private September 10, 1814 October 9, 1814

This individual may or may not be our subject.